Israel has made real, verifiable concessions to Arab states — but far fewer, and narrower ones, than the “Israel endlessly offers peace, Arabs endlessly reject it” narrative claims, and almost none involved giving anything to the Palestinians.
Egypt and Jordan
Israel withdrew fully from the Sinai Peninsula under the 1979 Egypt–Israel peace treaty1 — its largest territorial concession ever, trading land for peace, recognition, and security arrangements. In 1994 Israel signed the Treaty of Peace with Jordan2, whose terms provided security guaranties, management and sharing of water resources, the basis for economic relations, and provisions on refugees. This history of treaties shows a pattern: peace with neighboring states, not with the Palestinians.
The Abraham Accords
The Abraham Accords1 are a series of bilateral normalization agreements mediated by the United States that normalized relations between Israel and the United Arab Emirates and Bahrain on September 15, 2020, followed by Morocco and Sudan. These normalization agreements established diplomatic ties, trade, and direct flights between Israel and the Arab signatories. Notably, Israel gave up nothing to the Palestinians except “suspend[ing] plans for the annexation of the Jordan Valley” — a pause, not a concession — which is why the Saudi foreign minister warned that “without finding a pathway to peace for the Palestinian people … any normalization will have limited benefits,” and the UAE later called West Bank annexation a “red line”1.
Where the familiar framing goes wrong
The narrative presents this as one-sided generosity rebuffed — Barak and Olmert “[offered the Palestinians] a state … and the Palestinian leaders refused” (Paxpoint3). In fact, those 2001 and 2008 offers were never formal written offers, and Israel retained full control of 60% of the West Bank (Area C)4 indefinitely, while settlement construction continued throughout the Oslo era. Reading the treaties as written — land for peace with Egypt and Jordan, but nothing conceded on the Palestinian question — is not anti-Israel; it is holding every party to the standard of a completed deal.
Sources
- 1979 Egypt–Israel peace treaty en.wikipedia.orghttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arab%E2%80%93Israeli_normalization
- Treaty of Peace with Jordan paxpoint.orghttps://paxpoint.org/diplomacy-normalization/regional-peace-building/
- …this as one-sided generosity rebuffed — Barak and Olmert "[offered the Palestinians] a state … and the Palestinian leaders refused" paxpoint.orghttps://paxpoint.org/diplomacy-normalization/israel-peace-proposals/
- 60% of the West Bank (Area C) aijac.org.auhttps://aijac.org.au/fact-sheets/arab-Israeli-peace-plans/